Your IP says you're in Columbus, United States. Are you?
Every website gets this guess from your IP address. Compare it with where your browser thinks you are, and see how close it gets.
Your browser will ask for permission. Your location stays in this browser: nothing is sent to ip5.io, and the result only shows a distance and a direction, not where you are.
Location is off. That's the safest setting. Websites can still see your IP location, but not your exact one.